Custom Cakes

We’re excited to share that Afterpay is now available as a payment option for our custom cakes! If you’d like to use Afterpay, please let us know when submitting your inquiry.

When it comes to custom cakes With That in Mind thoughtfully incorporates our customers requests and inspiration photos into each custom cake design, ensuring the final creation reflects your vision while maintaining our signature style.

We use inspiration photos to better understand your vision, however, these will solely be used as reference. While your cake may be similar in style or inspired by a reference design of a creation of our own or another baker, it will not be an exact replica. 

To inquire about ordering a custom cake, please use our Special Request (LOCAL) link to submit an inquiry. We proudly serve Anderson, Indiana and the surrounding areas.